All Insights

Five Stars for a Conversation?

Tom Rendle Tom Rendle Jul 24, 2026 2 min read
Share

Some review profiles do not reflect customer outcomes.

They reflect sales conversations.

We have now seen pages filled with five-star reviews from people describing:

  • a consultation
  • an in-home assessment
  • a proposal meeting
  • a friendly salesperson
  • an explanation of solar
  • even a cancelled job

In some cases, the reviewer explicitly says they do not own a system from the company they are reviewing.

That is not a customer review.

That is not proof of workmanship.

That is not proof of installation quality, electrical competence, after-sales service, system performance, or long-term support.

It is simply review farming: building the appearance of trust by collecting stars from people who have not gone through the actual process of becoming a solar customer.

A pleasant conversation is not a completed project

A company should not look established because it collected dozens of five-star ratings from people reviewing a sales pitch.

Homeowners should be asking:

  • Did this person actually buy a system?
  • Was the system installed?
  • Did they mention workmanship?
  • Did they mention production, savings, or service after the sale?
  • Are these reviews about real outcomes — or just first impressions?

If the reviews are all about how “friendly,” “informative,” or “easy to talk to” the rep was, then the public is not looking at a track record of delivered solar projects.

They are looking at marketing disguised as reputation.

Read the words, not just the stars

Five-star ratings can be manufactured surprisingly easily when the only thing being reviewed is a conversation.

Real reputation is built after the install:

  • when the design holds up,
  • when the workmanship is clean,
  • when the system performs,
  • and when the company stands behind it.

Until then, a wall of glowing reviews may say far less than people think.

If someone openly says they do not own a system from the company, that should not be mistaken for proof that the company has earned its reputation.